Why Californian's Regret Moving to Boise Idaho in 2025

by Curtis Chism - Idaho

Let’s Get Real—Not Everyone Loves Boise

If you’re thinking about leaving California for Idaho, there’s something you need to hear.

I get asked all the time:
“What’s your biggest regret about moving to Idaho?”
And more importantly—“What do other Californians regret most after moving here?”

I’m from San Diego. My family had been in California for generations. I made the move, and I’ve helped dozens of other Californians relocate to Idaho since. I’ve seen it all—the wins, the struggles, and yes, the regrets.

Let’s break down what you really need to know.

The #1 Mistake People Make: Assuming Boise = All of Idaho

A lot of people move to Boise expecting wide open spaces, traditional values, and a slower pace of life. But what they don’t realize is that Boise is the most progressive and urban part of Idaho.

It’s a growing city with:

A major university (Boise State)
A more liberal political climate
Pride flags lining the North End and Bench neighborhoods
A Democratic mayor, just re-elected
Urban development, bike lanes, traffic, and a younger population

If you're expecting small-town, conservative Idaho... Boise might feel like a surprise.

What Some People Do Next: Move Again—or Move Back

The hardest stories? People who:

Move to Boise
Buy a home too quickly
Realize it's not what they wanted
Start questioning their decision entirely

For some, that means relocating to the suburbs of Boise, where the lifestyle is more aligned with what they were looking for. For others, unfortunately, it means packing up and heading back to California.

What You Might Actually Be Looking For

If you’re looking for space, quiet, and conservative values, here’s where you should really be looking:

✅ Eagle, Idaho

High-end homes, acreage, upscale country feel, still close to Boise.

✅ Star

One of the fastest-growing areas with rural charm and land. Great balance.

✅ Meridian

Suburban, family-focused, lots of retail. Leans more conservative than Boise.

✅ Kuna

Affordable, rural feel, great for families who want more space.

✅ Nampa & Caldwell

Further out, but great small-town feel with lower home prices.

✅ Middleton & Emmett

True countryside living with wide open spaces.

If you don’t want Boise’s pace or politics—look to the suburbs. That’s where many transplants end up loving life here.

Why Some People Move Back to California

While most people love living here once they find their place, some do leave. Here's why:

❄️ Weather

If you’re used to San Diego or LA, Idaho winters can be a shock.
Snow, freezing temps, and inversions (trapped clouds) that can last for weeks without sunshine can take a toll.

💼 Jobs & Economy

Idaho is growing, but it’s not California. Fewer high-paying jobs in tech, entertainment, or specialized industries.
Big projects like Micron and Meta are creating long-term opportunities, but job variety is still limited.

🍽️ Lifestyle Shift

Less dining variety, fewer events, slower pace. Some love it. Some feel isolated—especially without family or friends nearby.

💰 Cost of Living Reality Check

Home prices are still lower than California but not dirt cheap anymore. Boise housing has surged, though prices have stabilized since 2023.

My Honest Take: Do I Regret It?

Not at all.
I miss the beach. I miss the weather. I miss family.
But I own multiple homes here. I have more freedom. My lifestyle is less chaotic. I actually live, not just survive.

I love Idaho. But it’s not perfect.
And that’s why I always tell people—do your research.

Tips to Avoid Regret

Don’t just look at Boise.
Explore the entire Treasure Valley—especially the suburbs.
Understand the weather.
If you hate the cold or gray skies, plan for it.
Know your values.
Want traditional lifestyle? Pick the right town, not just the right state.
Talk to someone who’s done it.
I moved from San Diego to Boise. I help Californians do this every single week.

Want Help Finding the Right Spot?

If you’re serious about making the move to Idaho—but want to make sure you pick the right community—let’s talk.

📅 Book a free consult
📞 Call or text: 208-510-0427
📧 Email: info@chismteam.com

I’ll help you figure out where you’ll actually feel at home.

Final Thought

Boise is a great city—for the right person. But if you’re expecting traditional small-town Idaho and land for your kids to run free, you may need to look beyond Boise.

Do your homework. Tour the area. Talk to locals.

And if you need help, I’ve got your back.