Moving from California to Idaho? 11 Big Differences You Need to Know First

Are you thinking about leaving California for a fresh start in Idaho? You’re not alone. Thousands of families have packed up in search of more space, lower taxes, and a slower pace of life. But not everyone stays.

I’m Curtis Chism, a licensed REALTOR® who made the move from San Diego to Boise, Idaho. I now run a relocation-focused real estate business in the Treasure Valley, helping Californians decide whether Idaho is truly the right next chapter.

This guide gives you the real story—the good, the tough, and everything in between—so you can decide with clarity and confidence.

Table of Contents

• Population and Density: Idaho Is Way More Spread Out
• Traffic: Yes, It Exists—But It’s Not LA
• Cost of Living: Housing, Taxes, and Utilities
• Crime and Safety
• Taxes: Flat, Simple, and Lower
• Political Climate and Culture
• Gun Culture and Hunting
• Outdoor Lifestyle
• Small Business Environment
• Weather and Seasons
• Culture Shock: Who Thrives Here
• Is Idaho Right for You?

1. Population and Density: Idaho Is Way More Spread Out

California’s cities are packed. San Diego County alone has over 3.3 million people. Boise sits around 235,000, and the entire state of Idaho is still under 2 million residents.

Even with rapid growth, the Treasure Valley feels open compared to Los Angeles, the Bay Area, or Orange County. If wide-open space and room to breathe matter to you, Idaho delivers.

2. Traffic: Yes, It Exists—But It’s Not LA

Traffic in the Treasure Valley is growing, but it’s nowhere near California gridlock. Boise ranks roughly 25th nationally for congestion, compared to Los Angeles at #1 and San Diego around #12.

Commutes remain manageable, and infrastructure projects like Highway 16 are easing pressure in growing areas such as Meridian and Star.

3. Cost of Living: Save Big on Housing, Taxes, and Utilities

Boise’s median home price sits around $475,000, compared to $1M+ in Los Angeles, $1.1M in San Diego, and $1.3M+ in San Francisco.

Property taxes are typically between 0.4% and 1%, utilities are reasonable, irrigation water is inexpensive, and homeowners insurance is far less volatile than in wildfire-prone California.

4. Crime and Safety: A Clear Win for Idaho

Boise’s violent crime rate is well below the national average, and suburbs like Meridian, Eagle, and Star consistently rank among the safest communities in the country.

For families prioritizing safety and peace of mind, this is often one of Idaho’s biggest advantages.

5. Taxes: Flat, Simple, and Lower

• Income Tax: Flat 5.8%
• Sales Tax: About 6% (including groceries)
• Property Tax: 0.4–1% with a $125K homeowner exemption

Compared to California’s progressive income tax (up to 13.3%) and higher property tax burdens, Idaho’s system is predictable and business-friendly.

6. Political Climate: Conservative With a Blue Dot

Idaho leans strongly conservative, with a heavy emphasis on individual freedoms, gun rights, and local control. Boise stands out as a more progressive “blue dot” with its own cultural vibe.

Outside of Boise, expect traditional values, high civic engagement, and strong opinions about preserving Idaho’s identity.

7. Gun Culture: Normalized and Respected

Idaho is a constitutional carry state. Firearm ownership is common and culturally accepted, often tied to hunting and personal protection rather than politics.

While ownership is widespread, it’s generally low-key and practical.

8. Outdoor Lifestyle: A Way of Life

Idaho is built for the outdoors—hiking, hunting, fishing, river floating, skiing, and camping are part of daily life. Many families move here specifically to raise kids closer to nature.

9. Small Business Friendly Environment

Starting an LLC in Idaho costs under $150, with no annual $800 franchise tax like California. Contractor licensing is inexpensive, and business regulations are straightforward.

The tradeoff is that consumers must vet contractors carefully due to lower licensing barriers.

10. Weather: Four Seasons (and Inversions)

Idaho has true seasons. Summers are hot and dry, falls are crisp, winters bring snow and cold, and spring is unpredictable but beautiful.

Winter inversions can trap clouds in the valley, making January and February feel gloomy. Many locals plan sunny getaways during this time.

11. Culture Shock: It’s Real

Life in Idaho moves slower. There are fewer big-name restaurants, less nightlife, and less instant convenience. Some people love it. Others miss California’s pace and variety.

You’ll also see strong local pride—Idaho isn’t trying to become California, and fit matters here.

Is Idaho Right for You?

Idaho is a great fit if you want:

• Lower cost of living
• Safe, family-friendly communities
• Conservative values and personal freedoms
• Outdoor recreation and open space

Idaho may not be a fit if you:

• Need year-round warm weather
• Prefer dense urban living and constant entertainment
• Strongly dislike conservative cultural norms
• Struggle with seasonal changes

I moved from San Diego to Boise with my wife and three kids—and we never looked back. I’ve helped hundreds of families make this transition, and I’d be glad to help you decide if Idaho is right for you.

Call or text Curtis Chism at (208) 510-0427
Email: info@chismteam.com

Ready to relocate remotely? Download our Boise Relocation Guide